Vocalist Eamon Doyle insists that the message of "Your New Album Sucks" isn't as straightforward as the title might lead listeners to assume: "In the bridge, I sing: 'I don't want you to grow or reinvent or explore / You're out of print, so take the hint / And just do what you did before.' Many devotees of popular music develop that sense of entitlement to immediate gratification. The song argues both sides of the issue, one explicitly, one implicitly."